Showing posts with label Book Review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Book Review. Show all posts

Friday, December 28, 2012

Book Review: The Enchanted Flute by James Norcliffe

I will preface this post by saying that urban fantasy has never held much of a draw for me. I am more interested in history and an "older" voice, and I tend to be caught off guard by modern language in books, I read so much of the older stuff.

It all started with a flute in the window of a seedy old pawn shop. Taking it home, Becky discovers that she can't play it--rather, it makes her play only one song: Syrinx by Debussy. Drawn to its old owner, Dr. Faunus, the song that Becky is forced to play seems to enchant the old man into youth. Running from his house with that nerd Johnny Cadman, the two youths are thrown into a mythical land and chased to the ends of it, all for the sake of one enchanted flute.

Becky and I didn't hit it off right away. She kept calling Johnny Cadman a nerd like it was a negative thing, and being a nerd myself, I took offense. I also didn't believe some aspects of her character. There was one scene where she described herself as a good listener, but given that she wouldn't give Johnny the time of day previous to that scene, I had trouble believing her claims. That said, she did become more bearable as the story went on. Even then, I didn't feel particularly connected to her or the other characters in the story. They lacked the kind of depth I usually like to see.

That said, the plot of this book was--well--enchanting. An enchanted flute, an old man with goat hooves, characters thrown into a mystical land with magical creatures, gods and goddesses all made for an entertaining read. The setting was well described, though I wish the music the flute played had been described a bit better. I ended up listening to it on YouTube, and while listening to the tune will always be better than reading about it, I would have liked to have more of an idea of what it sounded like.

The book was adventure packed and interesting and, more to the point, different than a lot of things I usually read. If you're looking for a fun, fast-paced read, look no further than The Enchanted Flute.

Thursday, December 27, 2012

Book Review: A Brief History of Montmaray by Michelle Cooper


A Brief History of Montmaray is the diary of Sophie FitzOsborne, princess of Montmaray—a fictional island kingdom off the coast of England. Sophie details her life living in her crumbling castle with her siblings, cousin, crazy old uncle, and faithful dog. While Sophie dreams of the more exciting life of a London Season, she isn’t ready for the excitement that awaits her when the Nazis invade her home ahead of World War II. What follows is a mad dash for their country—and their lives.

From what I’ve seen, this book has received a lot of mixed reviews, and I have to say that I for one am 100% in love with the whole series.

I think part of the criticism of the Montmaray books is that they don’t have a huge amount of plot to them. Personally, I fall in love with books because of the characters. Books that have stunning, relatable characters don’t need much of a plot—I think it’s fun enough roaming around in the character’s head and living their lives, for which Montmaray’s diary style works perfectly. Sophie is an endearing but imperfect narrator who cares deeply for her family, and will make sure that you will, too.

As a fantasy connoisseur, it surprised me that I liked this decidedly historical fiction series. I think my attraction was due to a) my current obsession with Downton Abbey (if you like the show, you’ll love these books!) and b) the well-drawn setting, which turned the kingdom of Montmaray into a magical island plonked straight into the middle of one of my favorite periods of history.

That said, this book isn’t for everyone, which is why there are so many mixed reviews. It isn’t packed full of action—most of the real action is at the very end. Someone looking for an adventure won’t find it here. There also isn’t a lot of romance, save for a teenage crush—exactly what you might find in a sixteen year old’s diary.

I found that the series—The FitzOsbornes in Exile, followed by The FitzOsbornes at War—got even better as it went on, delving into London Society and the horrors of the Blitz. There were sad moments—heart-wrenching moments. But there were happy moments, too. If you enjoy history, Downton Abbey, or lovable characters, this is a series that you won’t want to miss.


**This book is often compared to I Capture the Castle, which I haven’t read, which is why there are no comparisons in this particular review.